Slavery and the North
An 1855 tract by Charles Burleigh, a well-known speaking agent for the American Anti-Slavery Society. Digitized by the Antislavery Literature Project.
"In the month of May, 1834, while one evening strolling up Broadway, New York, I saw a crowd making its way into the Minerva Rooms, and, having no pressing engagement, I followed, and was soon in a splendid hall, where some twelve or fifteen hundred persons were seated, and listening to rather a strange-looking man. The speaker was tall and slim, with long arms, long legs, and a profusion of auburn or reddish hair hanging in ringlets down his shoulders; while a huge beard of the same colour fell upon his breast. His person was not at all improved by his dress. The legs of his trousers were shorter than those worn by smaller men: the sleeves of his coat were small and short, the shirt collar turned down in Byronic style, beard and hair hid his countenance, so that no redeeming feature could be found there; yet there was one redeeming quality about the man—that was the stream of fervid eloquence which escaped from his lips. I inquired his name, and was informed that it was Charles C. Burleigh. Nature has been profuse in showering her gifts upon Mr. Burleigh, but all has been bestowed upon his head and heart. There is a kind of eloquence which weaves its thread around the hearer, and gradually draws him into its web, fascinating him with its gaze, entangling him as the spider does the fly, until he is fast: such is the eloquence of C. C. Burleigh. As a debater he is unquestionably the first on the Anti-slavery platform. If he did not speak so fast, he would equal Wendell Phillips; if he did not reason his subject out of existence, he would surpass him. However, one would have to travel over many miles, and look in the faces of many men, before he would find one who has made more personal sacrifices, or done more to bring about the Emancipation of the American Slaves, than Mr. Charles C. Burleigh." (Brown, Three Years in Europe, London, Charles Gilpin, 1852, 264-265)
Similarly, Parker Pillsbury observed of Burleigh that “On the platform, in argument, he had no superior and few equals.” (Acts of the Anti-Slavery Apostles, Concord, NH, 1883, 479-480) As well as engaging in lengthy speaking tours, Burleigh served as the antislavery editor of The Unionist and The Pennsylvania Freeman. He published Thoughts on the Death Penalty (1845), a notable early argument against capital punishment.
This tract reads as Burleigh might have spoken in his antislavery stump speeches. It presents a series of paragraphed arguments that address different objections to immediate emancipation. He addresses, for example, proslavery objections concerning ‘fitness for freedom’ by observing that the prevalence of illiteracy illustrates that “bad effect is no good reason for continuing the cause, but rather shows the need for its immediate removal. What!—shall we enslave men, because slavery makes them base?”(3) Freedom, he argues, acts to correct differences in social conditions between blacks and whites; slavery perpetuates these differences. Since slave-holders asserted that slaves were content in slavery, Burleigh points to this as a myth contradicted by abundant evidence to the contrary. (6-7) He is particularly concerned to address proslavery arguments in circulation in the northern states, such as a belief that emancipated slaves would leave the South en masse and lower wages in the North. (8-9) Burleigh condemns Northern inaction on slavery and concludes “The system is not southern only; it is national. Till this alliance with it is dissolved, the North is guilty with the South.” (12)
For further on Burleigh, see Ira V. Brown, An Antislavery Agent: C.C. Burleigh in Pennsylvania, 1836-1837, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 105 (1981) 1: 66-84.